Kelechi AmadiReal City Realty · Broker of Record
Home › Guide

How to Find Out What Your GTA Home Is Worth

By Kelechi Amadi, Broker of Record, Real City Realty Inc. · Updated October 9, 2026

Online estimates are quick, but they are guesses. If you are thinking of selling, you need a number you can actually plan around. This guide explains the different ways to value a home, what separates a good comparison from a bad one, and how to turn a value into a smart listing price.

Online estimates vs. a comparative market analysis

An automated estimate is a formula applied to public data. It does not know about your renovated kitchen, your busy street, or the layout quirk that buyers either love or hate. A comparative market analysis (CMA) done by an agent looks at what similar homes nearby have actually sold for and adjusts for the differences between those homes and yours.

Online estimates can be a starting point, but if you are making a decision as big as selling your home, you want a person to look at the property.

What a good comparison looks like

The best comparables are recent sales of homes that are similar in type, size, age, condition and location, ideally close by. Ask to see them. The sale price, the date it sold, the features, and how long it took to sell all matter.

Active listings matter too, because they are the competition buyers will compare you against. But a listing price is not a sale price, so do not treat what your neighbour is asking as what they will get.

What drives the value of your home

Why two similar homes can sell for different prices

Presentation, timing and pricing all matter. A home that is well prepared, photographed, and priced right at the start gets the most attention in the first days. A home with the same features that is rushed to market or priced too high may sell for less in the end.

CMA vs. appraisal

A CMA is an agent's market opinion, mainly used to decide how to price a listing. An appraisal is a formal valuation, often ordered by a lender for a mortgage. They answer different questions and will not always match. If you are refinancing or settling an estate, you may need an appraisal rather than a CMA.

Price to attract buyers, not to test the market

It is tempting to start high and come down. But homes that are priced too high often sit, then sell for less after price drops, because buyers wonder what is wrong with them. Pricing in line with recent sales gets the most buyers through the door in the first days, when attention is highest.

Your agent should explain the strategy behind a price and show you the evidence.

Know your net, not just your price

Your sale price is not what you walk away with. Factor in your mortgage payout (and any penalty for paying it out early), the agent's commission, legal fees, and any costs to prepare the home. If you are buying another home, add moving costs and the timing between the two.

In many cases, the sale of a principal residence is not taxed as a capital gain, but your situation may be different, so check with your accountant.

When is the right time to sell?

The best time is when your own plans line up with a market in which buyers are active. Spring and fall are often busy, but a well-priced home can sell at other times too. Your personal reasons, such as a job move or a growing family, usually matter more than trying to time the market perfectly.

Common questions

Is a CMA free?
Most agents provide a CMA at no cost and with no obligation, because it is how they show you how they would price and market your home.

Does a renovation always increase my sale price?
Not always, and not by the amount it cost. Ask your agent which improvements buyers in your area actually pay for before you spend money.

Should I get a pre-listing inspection?
It is optional. It can help you fix problems in advance and reduce surprises, but it is not required. Your agent can tell you if it makes sense for your home.

This guide is general information only and is not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules and costs change, so confirm the details for your situation with the right professional.

Get your free home value report

A comparable-sales based value for your home, with no obligation.

Get started, it's free

Prefer to talk? Call or text 416 275 4408